Published on: Aug 07, 2025 05:08 am IST
Hearing a plea filed by the Handcart Pullers Association seeking the introduction of e-rickshaws in place of the manual hand-pulled rickshaws, the court called the practice “inhuman” and “against the basic concept of human dignity”
MUMBAI: The Supreme Court on Wednesday directed the Maharashtra government to put an end to the functioning of hand-pulled rickshaws in Matheran within six months and switch to e-rickshaws, while calling the practice “inhuman” and “against the basic concept of human dignity”.
Hearing a plea filed by the Handcart Pullers Association seeking the introduction of e-rickshaws in place of the manual hand-pulled rickshaws, a bench comprising Chief Justice B R Gavai, Justice K Vinod Chandran and Justice N V Anjaria said, “Permitting such a practice, which is against the basic concept of human dignity in a country like India, belittles the constitutional promises of social and economic justice.”
While referring to a scheme in Gujarat where the government issued e-rickshaws to locals in Kevadia on rent, the apex court told the Maharashtra government to come up with similar schemes and also ordered the setting up of Matheran Monitoring Committee, under the chairmanship of the district collector, which will be responsible to identify the people to whom the e-rickshaw licenses shall be issued. The court added that the beneficiaries could also include tribal women to ensure them a steady livelihood.
The bench also noted that the state government should not make an excuse of a lack of funds and said, “We clarify that non-availability of funds cannot be an excuse for non-implementation of the aforesaid scheme. We earnestly hope that the state would tender necessary assistance in stopping such an inhumane practice.”
The court also told the state authorities to lay concrete paver blocks in Matheran and allow the local body to lay only clay paver blocks in the market area of the hill town, while making it clear that no paver blocks should be laid on the internal roads or the trekking routes of the hill town, which is the only pedestrian hill station in Asia and has been identified as an Ecologically Sensitive Zone (ESZ) by the Ministry of Environment and Forest and Climate Change.
